Heyo! I've got a new draft here: http://scpsandbox2.wikidot.com/dr-berggren under the tab "Aegides". Thanks for review and feedback!
I have 2 things to say about this one:
Zero-three-two-five
can you please change that to -0325(dash included)? It gets distracting for me.
Am I correct, then, in assuming that you [REDACTED]?
Does this really add anything to the article? because I really don't see a difference whether or not it's there, XXXX-0325 did something, so?
I personally find this a little weak compared to your previous ones, maybe others would disagree, but I don't like it much
MTF-Phi-10 ("Crawling In My Skin")
I'm trying so hard to not laugh in class right now goddammit
Okay, overall, this could feasibly succeed, but it needs work right now. I don't like the weird grammar presented in the interview, and the very last line feels like it's imitating a creepypasta-esque type of final line, which I don't think works in an article. However, I really, really liked the description of them as "hollow men," and thought that was the most interesting part of the article.
Acknowledged. The weird grammar is basically demonstrating that they can't talk in the past tense, they instead always talk in the present tense but append "then" or "now" to the sentence to denote when it happened.
I'm trying so hard to laugh in class right now goddammit
Why would you try to laugh in class?
What are you talking about, that "not" has always been there
I'm on a time crunch so I can't go overly in-depth, but here's my two bits:
People found to be hosting instances of SCP-XXXX — whether aware of, unaware of, acting in concert with, or attempting to resist their hosted instance
This is an unnecessarily lengthy way to say "all people found to host SCP-XXXX."
are to be incapacitated with minimum necessary force to the mouth, eyes, or groin.
I kind of feel like this is unnecessarily specific. "Incapacitated by non-lethal means" would be fine.
XXXX-Lerna containment methods
This is never mentioned anywhere in the description. What is it? It's kind of important to know this sort of thing in order to contain the scip.
similar to the shed skin of a snake,
Is this referring to the consistency of the skin, color of their skin, or both?
It may crawl under its host's clothing in order to achieve total coverage.
Is there a way it could achieve total coverage of a clothed host's body without going under the clothes? If so, that should be specified.
In one incident, several uncontained instances of SCP-XXXX were found to be controlling Foundation personnel in efforts to release contained instances. SCP-XXXX have no specific preference for types of humans to use as hosts in any regard.
I'd like this better if it said "refer to Incident Report XXXX-1" and went more in-depth on this, because this could lend quite a bit to the article.
I like the concept, but there's some tone issues. Polish this up a bit, and I'd look forward to seeing this being posted.
Although classified as parasitic, SCP-XXXX do provide some minor benefits to their hosts.
The word "parasite" does not necessarily imply that the specimen is harmful. Numerous beneficial parasites exist.
Those (beneficial organisms living on something) tend to be called symbionts.
Those that don't cause a negative effect are commensales.
EDIT: In other words, when giving advice on a scientific subject, do friggin' factcheck before you say something.
The definition of symbiosis is controversial among scientists. Some believe symbiosis should only refer to persistent mutualisms, while others believe it should apply to any types of persistent biological interactions (i.e. mutualistic, commensalistic, or parasitic).
-Wikipedia
Perhaps. Still, that makes symbiosis at worst as superset of (mutualism|commensalism|parasitism) - in none of these cases such a thing as beneficial parasitism exists - the issue is whether such behaviour is called symbiosis or mutualism.
Yes, that controversy would mean that sometimes "symbiosis" could include parasitic. But that redefinition would in no way negate a parasite being harmful to the host.
Directly from wikipedia "parasite":
Parasitism is a non-mutual relationship between organisms of different species where one organism, the parasite, benefits at the expense of the other, the host.
The word "parasite" always implies a net negative effect for the host.
And in the case of the hollow men, the negative effect for the host is that the parasite has total control over their physical movements, voice, cardiovascular system, and even eyes.
Edits have been made, further review is appreciated.
I still don't like the Engrish speech they have, but I like how this is progressing. Even so, I personally think it could be better if you develop it more. I like it either way, though.
The hollow men lose a bit of their humanity in the transition, so to speak.
How do you feel it could be improved further?
I would personally like to see expansion on how threatening/widespread these things are. But, given that that's what I usually like writing about, this advice should be taken with a grain of salt.
They generally cannot feel pain and do not need to breathe.
I dunno why but I just feel that you should change this sentence to
"They are generally unable to feel pain and don't require respiration due to their lack of nervous and circulatory systems"
It's just me, if you like your version, feel free to keep it the way it is, and vice versa, otherwise,
I also happen to like this version a lot better, congrats Breggren, you're on your way to becoming my favorite author.
I would upvote the current draft.
Piffy is an SCP Foundation Moderator, Lv. 9001 Squishy Wizard, and Knight of the Red Pen.






