I agree that the idea isn't quite all there yet, but I had trouble coming up with anything to add. It's an interesting problem. My feeling is that even aside from the whole cannibalism thing, it's not far enough from the real-life toxic Gyromitras, which sound pretty horrible on their own.
Not anomalous enough then? At least that gives me a bit of purchase. Not anomalous enough is better than "it's anomalous alright, but unfortunately it's also crapola of the highest order".
Also not a fan of the expungement ("Samples of SCP-XXXX that pass through the human digestive system, will [DATA EXPUNGED] mandatory incineration."); there aren't enough details in the writeup to imply what's been removed.
Right on that one too. Expungement and I are not friends. Will look hard at that.
You may want to change the "subjects do not acquire any specific craving for human flesh" note, for logical reasons. Most people who eat a mushroom, especially a mushroom which is related to those known to be poisonous, and then get sick from it, are not going to respond to being sick by trying to eat more of the mushroom. Nor would someone try to eat human flesh if there was anything else available to eat, unless cannibalism had suddenly become a lot more appealing.
That's kind of the point, really. Any other form of sustenance will kill you unless you keep injecting yourself with high doses of epinephrine. Which is why I wanted to point out that cannibalism is not a choice, it's a must.
There's also possibly a logical problem with a species of mushroom that requires humans in order to reproduce itself, as you suggest at the end, causing humans to eat other humans (and other mushrooms). Flowers don't kill the bees that pollinate them (though they do sometimes inconvenience them a lot), or kill the other flowers in the area. This might be something to elaborate on: a fungus that's evolved in seemingly counterproductive ways has some kind of story that explains why it had to be that way. So why'd it have to be that way?
See, that's what's missing. I think there's more people who read my draft and then went "the fuck do I say to that?". I'm looking for ways to make this logical ánd anomalous.
Anyway, thanks for your thoughts. I appreciate them.