Feedback will be very helpful. Any criticism is also welcome. Link below
Now that I've gotten a chance to read through it…. I can't even figure out how to critique it. It's so outlandish that it belies critique.
I get that you have something that's based on mathematical perfection, but aside from the mechanical issues (how is Φ grams "perfect"?), philosophical concepts made real tend to do really poorly as SCPs unless you can execute them perfectly, and I'm not seeing that here. The nature of philosophical concepts and questions is to address that which cannot be empirically solved; that kinda kills the Foundation meta-narrative and puts you in an awkward place where you can't scientifically develop the idea.
As it is, I would downvote this article. It's just too far outside the realm of plausibility. Also, those are massive walls of text.
As you know, this is a ROUGH DRAFT. Not being critical, but I am not finished with it. I appreciate all the criticism I received and I am making changes to it. Thank you for your feedback
Hence why I said "as it is". I can't read your mind, so I can't tell what you intend to do with it; I can only comment on it in its current form.
Also, as an aside, collapsibles are obnoxious. They are flow-breaking, annoying to click on, and prevent an article from being properly printed or converted into a PDF. I have gripes with "legitimate" uses of collapsibles, much less ones that only cover a single paragraph and therefore should just be a vanilla addendum.
I think I'll try and critique this, though I'm a bit apprehensive knowing that Aelanna thought is was outlandish.
SCP-#### must at all times be kept within a spherical plexiglass container.
I believe you misplaced "at all times", it might be more readable at the end of the sentence. And does the container really have to be spherical?
The glass must not be touching SCP-####
Tone… and how would this be possible?
else it will escape by unknown means and appear on the other side of the container
TONE…. And how far away from the container?
in order to keep it away from the glass
TONE… And mention those electromagnets first, otherwise it doesn't make sense.
must be shining upon
You know what? You have problems with tone everywhere, I can't help you with that. Read more articles on the wiki to get the feel of it.
to keep it in a stable behavior
……
In the event of an escape, the area at all costs must be evacuated as soon as possible
Might want to work on sentence structure over here, and here, and everywhere.
Any personnel not clear of the site within 10 minutes will be unintentionally terminated
What?!
The immediate area of 750 meters needs to be locked down
That is a ridiculously huge area.
Through several containers stored around the area, Compound-257 must be released and spread
I don't even…
SCP-#### will flee back to
Tone, son, TONE.
A group of 5 Class D personnel must enter the area
What area?
Two must keep a watch on SCP-#### while 3 assess and repair any flaws or weaknesses within containment walls.
We don't have to know this.
the group must leave the area and be sent to be examined for any traces of burning flesh
"burning flesh?" Really?
A Level 2 hazmat team of 6 must enter and repair the flaws found. Once the repairs have been made, the team must scan the entire containment area so to make sure the walls and glass meet the requirement. The team will then need to leave and be examined. The contaminated area may then be cleaned of Compound-257. After 24 hours of decontamination, all personnel previously working in the area may resume their normal routines.
I don't need to know this….
The contaminated area may then be cleaned of Compound-257. After 24 hours of decontamination, all personnel previously working in the area may resume their normal routines.
I suggest reading this to know what's cliche, and this for more information.
The material seems to be metallic, yet when touched it is reported to feel soft
its a mistery gais
It's mass is unknown. Density is unknown at the time of writing
Don't speak like this. Incomplete sentences are bad. They break the flow.
And really, how was it impossible to measure its mass?
Possibly hollow, yet unknown for sure.
This made me laugh.
Color is indeterminable as it emits a variety of hues.
It looks pretty dark in that picture of it to me!
SCP-#### has three recorded types of behavior. The first being a passive behavior where it is containable and unreceptive.
You could have put a comma there, but you decided to make sure your writing was choppy.
The second being an active behavior which is containable if already in it's containment
So if it's not in containment, it's uncontainable?
The affected then feel obligated to protect SCP-####
Oh boy, we've already got SCP's that do this.
Affected have reported to have knowledge beyond our current human understanding, as what they speak of is mainly far fetched
WHAT? FAR FETCHED? And the beginning of this sentence confused me.
SCP-#### has been reported to be able to break out of it's containment in one instance when in this behavior
in one instance?
Any human within 500 meters of SCP-#### is considered a target by it
That is a fucking huge radius, and when will you feex ur tone!?
in the dangerous behavior, there is no known way to calm it
Is this thing sentient or not? You're using verbs that would usually be bused for living organisms.
In time, SCP-#### cools down
Oh, so it gets really hot?
It has been observed to calm when no targets are present
Well, since it has a 500 meter radius, that would be near impossible.
Behaviors can be determined by temperature of the air surrounding SCP-####
So you put a halogen light bulb to keep it warm and not crazy?
Dr.███████ forbids all experimentation upon SCP-#### as of 05/27/█. Only Level 2 personnel with express permission from Dr.███████ may experiment.
You just said that none of the doctors and higher personnel can test this, yet you allow Level 2 to test it?
This should be in the containment procedures, even if it is completely unnecessary. And did you really have to put it in a collapsible for three sentences?
Upon Dr.███████'s unlikely death, Level 2 personnel may begin experimentation under supervision of Level 5 agents.
Level 2 personnel may begin experimentation under supervision of Level 5 agents.
under supervision of Level 5 agents.
Level 5 agents.
…That's it. I give up. This is a hopeless geometric shape that has a compulsive effect on a huge amount of area, and is not interesting in any way. You have a huge wall of text, the concept has no narrative, the tone is horrendous, and no regards to the Foundation's canon is given. And don't tell me "there is no canon", because I'm pretty sure there is no such thing as Level 5 agents.
If you want this to do any good, stick around the website for a lot longer. Please.






