Mostly concerned about the formatting and the general phenomenon here.
I really like the general idea, and that picture… bbbbbrrrruuuhhhh ….Enough to give me the shivers for sure. Tone seems good, the overall concept is pretty decent but I'm wondering does the house cause this effect since that is what you have listed as the actual SCP, or are the animals themselves anomalous? Did the house give them sapience? Just not sure what the implication here is. Overall very solidly written.
Also, forgot to ask this, what is it about this phenomenon that makes it a Keter class?
Oops, I was thinking of a different draft when I wrote Keter, silly me.
I would call this whole SCP more of a phenomenon, if anything. The house is SCP-XXXX, the guy found in it is SCP-XXXX-1 (and is the only non-anomalous thing here), and the pets of it are SCP-XXXX-2 and -3. Did you find it unclear in the article?
And I guess I should have stressed the SCP-XXXX-1 "yowls like a cat part". Maybe I'll edit this to make the implications clearer.
Thanks for the feedback!
Overview, Analysis, and Opinion
Brief Summary
Dead cat and dog that killed their owner because ghosts or something
Overall Thoughts
I like it. I like it a lot. You do a lot of good build up, and although there seem to be some logical flaws in the article at the moment, you can work on those as they get brought up. It's a solid, if a little predictable, piece in my opinion.
Verdict
Upvote.
Suggestions
- Work on the first interview log. It doesn't feel like natural dialogue.
- It seems like there's some logical inconsistencies in the article, but that might just be me. Either way, getting more reviews is a good thing.
- Fix the scientific labelling stuff I point out later in the critique
Specific Details/Line-by-Line
Special Containment Procedures
- There's nothing bad to note here, other than you've certainly got something set up that draws the reader in, which is a good thing. I like how you've basically set up the groundwork for some sort of story in this article, and now I really want to read the rest of it to find out what happened.
Description
All normal entry points to SCP-XXXX are currently inaccessible due to being locked from the inside, though they show signs of considerable wear and age.
Are we… like… unable to pick those locks? Or something?
Yowling similar to Felis Catus.
With binomial nomenclature, you always italicize and only capitalize the first word. i.e. It really should be Felis catus. Another thing is that although it is a fairly well known animal, it never hurts to also include the common name for the animal, as not everyone necessarily knows the Linnean classification for the domestic cat.
- Swearing and laughter, from a male human estimated to be around 40 to 50 years in age.
Just picking out this line arbitrarily; these bullet points also set up for an interesting backstory here, this is good.
Addenda
Got it. Those damn cat yowls are even louder than before. Sounds almost feminine.
This… well, that's really weird. Like, both in the fact that they sound like that, and the way he said it. I really can't imagine someone just naturally saying "Sounds almost feminine." I personally think you should tinker with that.
I see old and new spots on the ground and the wall, almost looks like wallpaper. Heh heh.
Dude what the fuck's up with this guy
It died due to blood loss approximately 1 hour later, and an interview was not possible at the time.
So, we couldn't get into the house before this? What?
This includes the an extension and increased mass in the Mandible, as well as in the Thoracic and Lumbar vertebrae, as well as the absence of the Caudal vertebrae. The muscle system corresponds with the anomalous areas, showing alterations in the Serratus Magnus, Lattisimus Dorsi, Masseter muscle, and Zigomaticus.
I'm fairly certain that none of these things should be capitalized.
SCP-XXXX-2 and SCP-XXXX-3 both display sapience, but only SCP-XXXX-2 has willingly communicated with personnel, which it accomplishes by scratching words onto material with its claws.
I… hm. Interesting.
Yeah, I think the agent came out sounding pretty fucking weird, most likely due to what time I was writing this. I can easily address everything else you pointed out. I think I might want I work on the implications in here as well, though.
Thanks a ton for the critique, I'm glad that you liked it!






